Tag Archives: anime

UN-GO — First Impression

There’s a lot to like, but a lot not to as well. First of all, the setting seems pretty cool. Political conspiracies, wars, and Napoleonic dress-up games. But we don’t have to reach too far back in our memories for another series Bones produced with a good setting. Furthermore, note that the purple haired transvestite’s Geass emits purple butterflies. What is it with Bones, noitaminA and butterflies? Recall that the first episode of No. 6 was pretty exciting and had a cool setting, but then they forgot about all that until the ending. I’m concerned that Bones will do the same thing once again, and focus on this purple haired kid instead of the setting.

UN-GO is also reminiscent of another Bones series with a detective duo. UN-GO does serve much better as a mystery than Gosick: it isn’t completely obvious from the get-go who the murderer is. And unlike Phi-Brain, where the puzzles require solutions that are impossible to find with the information given, UN-GO does a good job at information control. The viewer is able to solve the mystery with the information given, but it requires a bit of thought, and becomes increasingly clear as the sleuthing continues.

The biggest problems, though, are that I’m not sold on the characters and am also not entirely sure what’s going on. I think the latter problem will fade away as the series progresses, so I’m more worried about the characters. The pink haired kid, especially, seems annoying (in both forms). The lead female seems fairly useless. The two detectives look promising though.

As for blogging this, we’ll see how the next episode goes. I’m not too keen on blogging three series on Thursday, so I may not pick this one up depending on the second episode.

Liked this post? Leave a comment, subscribe to our RSS feed, and follow us on Twitter!

A Seasonal Review: Summer 2011

Summer was a great season.

I’ve loosely ranked the season’s shows from worst to best (rough guide to my rankings: A=awesome, B+=great, B-=good, C=decent, D=bad, F=fail). The numbers in parentheses are how I ranked that series’ first episode at the start of the season. Let’s see how much things have changed. Note that the numbers don’t exactly correspond, since the two-season shows were not included in the ranking at the start of the season.

I’ve tried to keep this post concise since I’ve already written full reviews for most of the shows. So let’s start!

Not Included: Hyouge Mono (only two eps. translated), Natsume Yuujinchou San (8) (haven’t watched second season)

Dropped After one Episode: Manyuu Hikenchou (24), Double-J (23), Morita-san wa Makuchi (22), Nyanpire (21), Twin Angel – Twinkle Paradise (20), Itsuka Tenma no Kuro Usagi (16)

23. Blood-C — Dropped (13)
I watched another episode or two, and they were the same as the first episode.

22. Nekogami Yaoyorozu — Dropped (19)
I just don’t find this funny. It’s more inclined to give me a headache than make me laugh.

21. Mayo Chiki — F (15)
Our standard harem of the season, with cross-dressing butlers.

20. Kamisama no Memochou — D- (10)
Generic and dull. I can’t stand any of the characters.

19. Ro-Kyu-Bu! — Not Finished (18)
Surprisingly decent for a lolicon show. But it’s still a lolicon show.

18. The iDOLM@STER — Still Airing (12)
There isn’t anything I can point to with this show and say “this is bad.” It’s actually very well made. It’s just that I have no interest whatsoever in idols.

17. Kamisama Dolls — D (4)
A cool setting, but utterly aimless.

16. Sacred Seven — D+ (11)
Fun and dumb.

15. Baka Test to Shoukanjuu Ni! — C- (14)
The jokes are getting old.

14. No. 6 — C- (2)
Had potential, but forgot about the main plot until the end, which was disastrous.

13. R-15 — C (17)
A solid and unique fanservice comedy.

12. Ao no Exorcist — C+
Standard shounen fare, but well made.

11. Gintama’
A good season, especially the prison arc.

10. Ikoku Meiro no Croisée — B- (7)
Undeniably adorable.

9.  Nurarihyon no Mago Sennen Makyou (6)
A vast improvement over the last season.

8.  Dantalian no Shoka — B- (3)
Very creative, but it got stale.

7.  Hanasaku Iroha — B
Great when it sticks to the drama.

6.  YuruYuri — B (9)
Hilarious yuri hijinks.

5.  Tiger and Bunny — B+
Great characters (especially Kotetsu) but a somewhat weak ending.

4.  Usagi Drop — B+ (5)
Lovable characters in roles we don’t often see, beautifully animated.

3.  Steins; Gate — B+
Great fun with time travel and speculation (and a badass lead character).

 

2.  Nichijou — A-
One of the best comedies in recent years. It’s left me laughing every week.

1.  Mawaru Penguin Drum (1)
By far my favorite series of the season. This show has a pacing and intensity that none can match, is always full of surprises, and gives plenty of food for thought every week.

What did you think of this season’s shows? Feel free to share in the comments!

Liked this post? Leave a comment, subscribe to our RSS feed, and follow us on Twitter!

Ao no Exorcist Review — C+

Rin discovers that he is the son of Satan. His foster father is murdered by Satan, and he decides to become an exorcist. He begins attending school, where his brother is a teacher.

This is straight-up shounen— fights, making friends, believing in yourself and all that jazz. But I enjoyed it. The first thing is the setting. I’m a sucker for religious motifs, even if it’s Crystal Dragon Jesus. Second is the characters. They’re all likable and have their own quirks.

The story itself isn’t much to write home about. It mostly follows the students’ school life as they train to defeat Satan. The ending seems to be unpopular, but I thought it was pretty good. It’s standard shounen, but what else would you expect?

  • Plot / Script – C – Your usual shounen.
  • Characters – B – Likable.
  • Production – B – It’s Bones.
  • Overall – C+

Recommendations – Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Nurarihyon no Mago

Liked this post? Leave a comment, subscribe to our RSS feed, and follow us on Twitter!

Isekai no Seikishi Monogatari Review — B+

Let’s not beat around the bush: most harem shows suck. There are the factors that I see as the biggest reasons why:

  1. The male protagonist is an indecisive loser with no redeeming features.
  2. Every female he meets inexplicably falls in love with him.
  3. Said female characters are usually taken straight out of the book with a single defining feature. As a few examples, take the imouto, the nee-san, the loli, the childhood friend, the tsundere, and the swordswoman.
  4. Nothing happens. The characters hang around the place they live all day (usually the same building), and the male trips on top of the females and walks in on them in the shower. He always likes all of the females equally.
  5. The show is boring.

Obviously, number five has the highest weight. Only a few harems manage to rise above the pack. One is Love Hina, which gets a pass from me by virtue of being the first harem I watched. Plus the main character is a loser, but not indecisive, and progress is actually made. Another is Kore wa Zombie Desu Ka?!, where #3 does not apply, and humor goes a long way in preventing boredom. The last decent harem I’ll mention (this list is non-exhaustive) is Ichiban Ushiro no Daimao, which avoids most of the problems by having a badass protagonist, an over the top story and more unique fanservice.

So how does Isekai no Seikishi Monogatari fit in? For item (1), our lead character, Kenshi, is certainly indecisive when it comes to girls. But this feels more like he isn’t interested in girls at all than indecisiveness, as he can be quite forceful in other matters. It’s unclear whether our hero has even reached puberty yet. No redeeming features? Not really, he’s ridiculously talented at everything he does to the point of absurdity.

Every female he meets (and every female he doesn’t meet) falls in love with him, so (2) certainly applies. Half the show is about Kenshi running away from hordes of girls. I would say that because the show fulfills this criteria to such an extent, it approaches parody. So it fulfills it, but not in the typical sense.

For (3), I thought that the female characters were actually fairly interesting. They may have one overriding trait (e.g., Lashara as a money grubber and Wahan as a mad scientist), but at least these aren’t the usual traits, and the characters have an existence outside of them.

Item (4) definitely does not apply to this show, as we actually have quite an interesting, albeit typical, fantasy story. The setting is creative and well-fleshed out, we have a great set of villains and allies, and a focused narrative. There are mecha, floating fortresses, armored trains and spider robots. It’s not the most original story, but the execution is solid, especially because of the extra length episodes.

As for (5), I didn’t find it boring at all, largely because of the fantasy / adventure story which made this more than just a harem. My overall feeling is, harems are fine, as long as they have more than just a harem. (Maybe that means they aren’t fine? Whatever.) Ichiban Ushiro no Daiamao and Kore wa Zombie Desu Ka have comedy to keep them afloat, and Isekai no Seikishi Monogatari has its fantasy story.

  • Plot / Script – A – A fantasy story that could stand on its own (although not as strongly) without the fanservice and harem elements.
  • Characters – B – Kenshi’s entertaining because he’s so good at everything and also so dumb. Lashara has a contagious evil laugh (I am quite partial to evil laughs).
  • Production – B – Solid, although a bit underwhelming for a show of this format.
  • Overall – B+

Recommendations – Kore wa Zombie Desu Ka?!, Ichiban Ushiro no Daimao

Liked this post? Subscribe to our RSS feed and follow us on Twitter!

Mayo Chiki Review — F

A classy screen shot for a classy show.

This is the harem adaptation of the season. The main twist is that we have a cross-dressing butler. Except it’s completely obvious that she’s a girl. How can anyone be fooled by this? Besides, she isn’t nearly as cute as Hayate.

The other characters include a monstrous little sister, a girl obsessed with glasses, a tsundere, and an ojou-sama. The male protagonist is a spineless wuss.

The main reason I managed to finish this show is Kanade. She’s quite the ojou-sama, and at least managed to spice things up a bit. Still, it wasn’t enough to save Mayo Chiki from its own bland premise.

  • Plot / Script – F – Your usual harem setup.
  • Characters – D – Kanade redeems things slightly. And Usagi wasn’t bad as far as tsunderes go.
  • Production – C – Nothing special.
  • Overall – F

Recommendations – Hayate no Gotoku, Love Hina

Liked this post? Leave a comment, subscribe to our RSS feed, and follow us on Twitter!